Head to head

Pick two contenders to compare their scores and their run-off match-up.

Portrait of Jean-Luc Mélenchon
7.3/10
Portrait of Éric Zemmour
4.5/10

If they met in the run-off

Jean-Luc Mélenchon 37.3% 62.7% Éric Zemmour

Model projection based on the latest first-round polls and on vote transfers calibrated on run-off polls. See the method.

Their proposals

ThemeJean-Luc MélenchonÉric Zemmour
Pensions Repeal the 2023 reform and restore retirement at 60 after 40 years of contributions. Legal retirement age of 64 (2022 programme).
Work and purchasing power A minimum wage of €1,600 net, wages indexed to inflation, a price freeze on basic necessities. No specific proposal known.
Taxes and spending Restore a strengthened wealth tax, move to 14 income-tax brackets and cap inheritances. Cut production taxes and reject any wealth tax (2022 programme).
Immigration Regularise undocumented workers and repeal the 2024 immigration law. “Zero immigration” and “remigration”: an end to birthright citizenship and family reunification, very limited asylum, expulsion of foreign offenders and jobless foreigners.
Europe and defence Non-alignment and leaving NATO's integrated command; disobey European treaties that would block the programme. Leave NATO's integrated command (2022 programme).
Energy and climate Gradual exit from nuclear power and 100% renewable energy, through ecological planning. Relaunch nuclear power and stop wind power (2022 programme).
Institutions and security A Sixth Republic drafted by a constituent assembly and put to a referendum; a citizens' initiative referendum. Criminal majority at 16 and mandatory minimum sentences.

All programmes and their sources

Overlaid profiles

Experience Name recognition Communication Polls Reach Party machine

Jean-Luc MélenchonÉric Zemmour

Criterion by criterion

MélenchonCriterionZemmour
8 Experience
2
10 Name recognition
9
9 Communication
7
7 Polls
3
2 Reach
1
8 Party machine
5
7.3 Overall score 4.5