Head to head

Pick two contenders to compare their scores and their run-off match-up.

Portrait of Raphaël Glucksmann
5.8/10
Portrait of Jean-Luc Mélenchon
7.3/10

If they met in the run-off

Raphaël Glucksmann 58.3% 41.7% Jean-Luc Mélenchon

Model projection based on the latest first-round polls and on vote transfers calibrated on run-off polls. See the method.

Their proposals

ThemeRaphaël GlucksmannJean-Luc Mélenchon
Pensions Repeal the 2023 reform and give a council run mainly by the social partners the task of steering pensions. Repeal the 2023 reform and restore retirement at 60 after 40 years of contributions.
Work and purchasing power Rebalance taxation, which weighs more on work than on capital and inheritance, so that work pays more. A minimum wage of €1,600 net, wages indexed to inflation, a price freeze on basic necessities.
Taxes and spending The Zucman tax: a 2% minimum tax on fortunes above €100 million; tax very large inheritances. Restore a strengthened wealth tax, move to 14 income-tax brackets and cap inheritances.
Immigration Legal routes for labour immigration, asylum claims processed within six months, repeal of the 2024 immigration law. Regularise undocumented workers and repeal the 2024 immigration law.
Europe and defence Autonomous European defence funded by €500 billion of joint borrowing; more military aid to Ukraine; a more federal Europe. Non-alignment and leaving NATO's integrated command; disobey European treaties that would block the programme.
Energy and climate Consolidate the nuclear fleet and build new reactors, with electricity prices based on French production costs. Gradual exit from nuclear power and 100% renewable energy, through ecological planning.
Institutions and security No specific proposal known. A Sixth Republic drafted by a constituent assembly and put to a referendum; a citizens' initiative referendum.

All programmes and their sources

Overlaid profiles

Experience Name recognition Communication Polls Reach Party machine

Raphaël GlucksmannJean-Luc Mélenchon

Criterion by criterion

GlucksmannCriterionMélenchon
4 Experience
8
7 Name recognition
10
7 Communication
9
5 Polls
7
6 Reach
2
6 Party machine
8
5.8 Overall score 7.3